Ganesh Sittampalam (hsenag) wrote,
Ganesh Sittampalam

Stupid legislation

I'm sure many people have already picked over the Terrorism Act 2000 in much detail, but I only just now noticed how stupid some of it is.

I was reading this news story. A has been charged with having B's name and address, which apparently is a crime because B is a soldier and A has a Muslim name (OK, the "A having a Muslim name" bit isn't mentioned in the charge, but the rest is..)

It seemed like a bit of a sweeping offence, so I went to consult the relevant section, and indeed possessing any information likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism is a crime. Eeek! I'd better destroy any records I have of the address of my friend in the RAF, then. Oh, wait, clause (3): "It is a defence for a person charged with an offence under this section to prove that he had a reasonable excuse for his action or possession." So as long as I'm happy with being considered guilty until I can prove myself innocent, I'm probably OK. Great.

Actually, I'd better be careful about having any information at all. After all, if I have a record of where the nearest supermarket is, a terrorist might be able to use that to get some food, which would certainly be useful to him or her.

Scrolling on down to sections 59-61, yet more stupidity. The section essentially says "It's a crime to incite someone to do something outside the UK if it would be one of a certain set of crimes in the UK." Obviously they then thought that this might get the Armed Forces etc in trouble, so they added clause (5): "Nothing in this section imposes criminal liability on any person acting on behalf of, or holding office under, the Crown." So anyone who holds office under the Crown can do what they like in terms of incitement, whether or not they are acting on behalf of HMG at the time.

I'd love to know what idiot wrote this law.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

Yikes. Everyone is losing their head.
Until I got to the "clause 3" part, that suggested to me that various of your friends oughtn't to know where they themselves work...
Plus, I suppose a lot of skills such as those taught in electronics at school and uni ought not to be taught. Do you think they'll arrest all the physics teachers?


July 8 2005, 13:16:44 UTC 11 years ago

Bloody Liberal, it's people like you that are causing the horrific scenes in London. Roll on ID cards and house arrest for all forigners (and those that look forign, and child molesters, in fact people who look like that might at some point in the future be a forigner, or child molester)